TM -Elucidation - the true backgrounds of the TM- Meditation - movement

The Shankara Order ( Guru Dev's succession)

1. The illusions of connections of the TM movement to the tradition of the Shanakara Order

Adi Shankaracharya reorganised the Sannyasis in India into ten main groups known as the Dasanami Tradition of Advaita vedanta. These orders are also allocated to four different maths of the Shankara Order. (The seven Dasanami Akhadas ( Juna, Niranjani, Mahanirvani, Ananda, Atal, Avahan, Agni )  have their own leaders.)

The principal eastern (Purvamnaya), southern (Dakshinamnaya) and western (Pascimamnaya) institutions are at Puri (Orissa), Sringeri (Karnataka) and Dwaraka (Gujarat) , while the northern (Uttaramnaya) Sankaracharya seat is at Jyotirmath (also known as Joshimath) near Badrinath.  In northern india are three competing lines, that is the Shankara seat of Jyotirmath, further the Madhava Asrama and the Krishnabodha Asrama.

Swami Brahmananda Saraswati was born  1870 in the village Gana in Ayodhya. He found his master Dandi Swami Krishnanand Saraswati at the age of 14 in Uttarkashi in the Himalayas. In 1902, at the age of 34, he was accepted into the order of sannyasins by his master at the Kumbh Mela and then initiated into the deeper meaning of the teachings.

In 1936 he established his ashram at Shri Brahma Niwas D.61/28 Siddhagiri Baag, Sigra 221010 Varanasi.

In 1938 he established Shri Brahmanandaswar Mandir - a temple at D 60/30, Choti Gaivi, DIST.:Varanasi 273005 Uttar Pradesh on Shukravar 10 Shravana 1995

On April 1st 1941 he accepted the position of Shankaracharya of Jyotirmath, and this was formalised at his ashram at Siddhagiri Baag. He was appointed the owner of the northern chair of Jyotirmath of the Indian Shankara Order, which had been orphaned for over 150 years, in 1941 by a group of monks and experts from Varanasi (Bharata Dharma Mahamandala, Kashi Vidvat Parishad, and the Akhila Bharatiya Dharmasangha).*  The Jyotirmaṭha Śaṅkarācārya Lineage in the 20th Century, Vidyāśaṅkar Sundareśan

Maharishi Mahesh Yogi (* 12. Januar 1918 as Mahesh Verma Shrivastava or Mahesh Prasad Varma in Pounalulla, India; † 5. Februar 2008 in Vlodrop, Netherlands) was  just a sadhu and the secretary of Guru Brahmananda Saraswati, the owner of the northern Shankara seat of Jyotirmath, who  suddenly died of poisoning after 12 years of activity on May 20, 1953. (Brahmananda Saraswati ; [video])

The  successorship was first offered to Guru Devs disciple Swami Hariharananda Saraswati who refused.

📃 Then a testament of 8.12.1952 became public. In the controversial testament(which had been changed half a year before guru devs death), Gurudev Brahmananda Saraswati had named four  candidates as successors, who were all not really qualified. The first was Swami Shantanand Saraswati, who did not at all measure up to the qualifications as described in the Mahanusasana texts. The others were Swami Dvarakesananda Saraswati,  Swami Vishnudevananda Saraswati and  Swami Paramatmananda Saraswati (Ramji Tripathi, Dwarika Prasad, Vishnu Devanand and Parmanand Saraswati).

There was then a dispute over the controversial succession with the above disciple Vishnu Devanand Saraswati since 1953, who had simply settled himself, which  had to be clarified lengthy at court.

== Mahanusasana-Texts ==

* Requisite qualifications for a Shankaracharya are contained in the following two verses of "Mathamnaya": "He who is unsullied, has subdued the senses, is well versed in the Vedas and Vedangas, and is conversant with the application of the shastras can obtain my Peeth otherwise, one devoid of these merits even if installed, is to be deposed by the wise and learned."

So relevant organizations (Kashi Vidwatpeeth und Bharat Dharma Mahamandal e.o.) involved in reviving Jyotir Math, proposed instead Swami Krishnabodha Asrama, who resided until his death in 10. December 1973 as the Shankaracharya, despite Shantanand's claim and occupation of Jyotir Math. Though Krishnabodha's choice was 1970 annuled by a civil court, but Krishna Bodhashram continued to claim that he was the real Shankaracharya.

Krishna Bodhashram didn't nominate his successor.  Kashi Vidwatpeeth and Bharat Dharma Mahamandal, a group of saints who have got the right to entrust additional charge of a mutt to a revered saint in case the successor is not nominated, handed over the Jyotir Mutt to Swami Swaroopanand in 1973. 

In 1979,  a conference of the Sankaracharyas of the four Amnaya mathas was held at Sringeri, and

Santananda and Vishnudevananda were not invited. It was instead  Swarupananda Saraswati, a direct disciple of Brahmananda Saraswati and later of  Swami Krishnabodha Asrama, who had represented Jyotirmath parallel until his death in 1973. The rival lineage of Shantananda and his disciples was not endorsed at this time by any of the other Sankaracharyas.

Swami Shantanand Saraswati visited Maharishi in Rishikesh  during his teacher training in 1961 and was receipted with all ceremony. He praised Maharishi that he wanted to spread the simple Mantra-Meditation worldwide (at that time still almost costless).

Also later Shanatanand redirected deeper questions  regarding Vedanta to Dandi Swami Bhagawatananda Saraswati (Dandi Swami: The Story of the Guru's Will, Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, the Shankaracharyas of Jyotir Math, & Meetings with Dandi Swami, Paul Mason).

* alt.meditation.trans : The True Lineage of Jyothirmath

So Shantananda was until 1980 the rival chair owner und then went into the Madhava Asrama. He was followed up by Vishnu Devanand Saraswati, who died 1987, while Shantananda still lived until 1997 in Madhava Asrama.

Parallel Swami Swaroopanand Saraswati, a direct disciple  of Gurudev and Krishnabodha and meanwhile also Shankaracharya of Dwarka peeth and a harsh critic of Maharishi, clarified Mr. Kropinski about Maharishi in 1987.

== Vasudevananda ==

Vishnu Devanand Saraswati  was followed up by a Vasudevanand Saraswati, who was not a Sanyasi before 1989. He was a teacher in a government-aided school and drew salary until November 13, 1989. (* Alt.meditation.transcendental : Vasudevananda). Therefore he did not have the necessary qualifications.

Vasuedevanand processed since  1989 for his successorship. In 1989 he  produced a will of Krishna Devanand, claiming that he was nominated by his guru as the next Shankaracharya. But the court found that Vasudevanand was never a disciple of Krishna Devanand and the 300page document, dated April 7, 1989 produced by him, was fake. 

== Swami Madhavashram ==

In the meantime, a Swami Madhavashram, a disciple of Swami Krishnabodhashram,  presented himself as official Shankaracharya of Jyotirmath. But  he was only accepted by the Vidwat Parishad and died 2017 ailing at the age of 73, among other things because 1998 an attac had been carried out on him by Naga-Sadhus.

Vasudevanand and Swami Swaroopanand Saraswati processed further, and 2015 Vasudevanada was forbidden to collect money under the title of a Jagadguru of the Shankara order.

* 2015 : Court Declares 'Shankaracharya' Vasudevananda's Claim to Title Illegal

The next dispute before the Supreme Court in Allahabad ended 2017 with the result, that Vasudevanada has no claim and Swami Swaroopanada cannot have 2 chairs. It ordered a new election within 3 months. In the meantime, Swaroopananda was appointed caretaker.

It appears a successor has not yet been appointed, and Vasudevanand still travels around as unofficial Shankaracharya, wooded and supported by the TM-Movement.

* 2017 Badrinath shrine dispute ends

*** In September 2022 Swamit Swaroopanand died at the age of 99. Swami Avimukteshwaranand has been made the head of Jyotishpeeth Badrinath, and Swami Sadanand has been made the head of Sharda Peeth Dwarka. The names of both were announced in front of the body of Shankaracharya.

`* Avimukteshwaranand new Jyotish Peeth shankaracharya Indiatimes - September 14, 2022

* Relevant and critical weblinks :

Youtube - videos :